When Formality Is Costly and Informality Is Legal: Understanding the Administrative Burden of Social Insurance System Design in Low and Middle-Income Countries

Funding Sponsor

Ford Foundation

Author's Department

Public Policy & Administration Department

Second Author's Department

Public Policy & Administration Department

Find in your Library

https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.70042

All Authors

Irene N. Selwaness Ghada Barsoum

Document Type

Research Article

Publication Title

Public Administration and Development

Publication Date

1-1-2025

doi

10.1002/pad.70042

Abstract

This paper looks at the extent to which the institutional framework for social insurance (SI) constrains access to contributory schemes, with data from Egypt. We use nationally representative microdata to test how the design results in the exclusion of specific categories of workers. Our findings show that the country witnessed a decline in SI coverage among regular wage workers, despite stipulations of mandatory coverage for this group. The analysis highlights two reinforcing dynamics: legal informality, where workers are excluded by design from joining the system; and costly formality, where workers and employers are deterred by rising contribution floors. The administrative burden relating to conditions of enrollment, contribution costs, and benefit design disincentivize both employers and employees to contribute to the system. The paper also shows that the burden is gendered, as women encounter higher compliance costs due to fragmented work trajectories and informal employment spells.

Link to Full Text
Find this item online

Share

COinS